Trivia Question - With a bonus

The first correct responder emailed to ccss1994@yahoo.com will win our fourth gift certificate to Stables plus an additional bill bearing the face of our President during the Blue and Gray era (compliments of Tinker) if you also name that game's winning pitcher. Who got the first hit in Carroll County Senior Softball's inaugural game in 1994 (he also ended his career with a hit)? Hint for the bonus--His namesake portrayed Col. Sherman Potter.